Challenger vs Charger

Challenger and Charger differ mainly in doors. They share similarities in engine, pricing, and seating capacity. Manual transmission is exclusive to the Challenger.

Salman Chaudhary, Founder Pinkywheels.com

12/9/2023

Challenger vs Charger
Challenger vs Charger

Challenger vs Charger

2023 Challenger vs 2023 Charger

Charger vs Challenger

In the ever-evolving realm of the automotive industry, the Dodge Charger sedan and Dodge Challenger coupe stand out as stalwart contenders, defying the test of time in their respective market niches. Anchored in a shared foundation of the rear-wheel-drive Chrysler LX platform, these formidable vehicles draw upon their iconic muscle car lineage to captivate enthusiasts and buyers alike. However, beneath the surface of their common platform lies a tapestry of distinctions, as the two- and four-door configurations of Dodge's flagship models each carve a unique niche in the automotive landscape.

The Charger, with its four-door sedan design, presents a fusion of practicality and performance, catering to those seeking a harmonious blend of spacious interiors and dynamic driving experiences. On the other side of the spectrum, the Challenger, a quintessential two-door coupe, exudes a nostalgic charm reminiscent of the classic muscle car era, placing a strong emphasis on raw power and a more driver-centric experience.

As we embark on a comparative journey between the Dodge Charger and Challenger, our goal is to unravel these nuances, shedding light on the distinctive features and characteristics that define each model. By navigating through the intricacies of the Charger vs. Challenger debate, we aim to equip you with the insights necessary to make an informed decision, ensuring that your choice aligns seamlessly with your automotive preferences and lifestyle.

2023 Challenger vs 2023 Charger Highlights:

  • Price:

  • 2023 Charger: Starting MSRP of $34,240

  • 2023 Challenger: Starting MSRP of $34,395

  • Configurations:

  • Charger: SXT, GT, RT, Scat Pack, Scat Pack Widebody, SRT Hellcat Redeye Widebody, Jailbreak

  • Challenger: SXT, GT, R/T, R/T Scat Pack, R/T Scat Pack Widebody, SRT Hellcat, Jailbreak, SRT Hellcat Widebody, SRT Hellcat Widebody, SRT Hellcat Redeye Widebody, SRT Super Stock

  • Horsepower:

  • Charger: 292 - 797 HP

  • Challenger: 303 - 807 HP

  • Fuel Economy:

  • Both models: 19 city / 30 hwy MPG

  • Engine Options:

  • Charger: Supercharged 6.2L HEMI High-Output SRT V8, 392 HEMI V8, 5.7L HEMI V8, 3.6L PENTASTAR V6

  • Challenger: Supercharged 6.2L HEMI High-Output SRT V8, Supercharged 6.2L HEMI V8, 392 HEMI V8, 3.6L PENTASTAR V6

  • Transmission(s):

  • Charger: 8-speed automatic

  • Challenger: 8-speed automatic, 6-speed manual

  • Torque:

  • Charger: 260 - 707 lb-ft

  • Challenger: 268 - 707 lb-ft

  • Drivetrain(s):

  • Both models: RWD, AWD

  • Seating Capacity:

  • Both models: 5

  • Infotainment System(s):

  • Both models: 8.4-inch Uconnect

  • Passenger Volume (cu.ft.):

  • Charger: 105

  • Challenger: 94

Challenger vs Charger
Challenger vs Charger

Challenger vs Charger: Passenger Space

Dodge Charger: Winner

Within the 2023 Dodge Charger, a distinct advantage surfaces in the realm of passenger space, establishing this large four-door sedan as a leader in accommodating occupants with unparalleled comfort. This advantage becomes particularly pronounced when compared to its counterpart, the 2023 Dodge Challenger, a two-door coupe with a more confined interior configuration.

The Charger's commitment to providing a spacious and comfortable environment for both the driver and passengers is evident in its capacity to technically seat five occupants. Notably, the Charger's rear legroom takes center stage with an expansive 40.1 inches, presenting a stark contrast to the more constrained 33.1 inches offered by the Challenger. This surplus of legroom in the Charger contributes significantly to a more relaxed and enjoyable experience for passengers seated in the rear.

However, the advantages extend beyond mere legroom. Rear-seat occupants in the Charger revel in an additional 4 inches of shoulder room, creating an atmosphere of openness and freedom within the cabin. The Charger's generous hip room, providing an extra 8.3 inches compared to the Challenger, further distinguishes it as a people-centric vehicle, prioritizing passenger comfort and space.

As we delve into the nuanced dimensions of the 2023 Dodge Charger, the emphasis on superior passenger space emerges as a defining characteristic that sets it apart in the Charger vs. Challenger comparison. Whether it's the extended legroom, the extra shoulder room, or the additional hip room, the Charger establishes itself as the preferred choice for those who seek a spacious and accommodating ride, making every journey a journey in comfort and style.

Challenger vs Charger: Cargo Capacity

Dodge Charger: Winner

In the realm of cargo capacity, the 2023 Dodge Charger emerges as the superior contender, boasting a larger trunk compared to its counterpart, the Dodge Challenger. While the Charger's advantage in cargo space is perceptible, it's noteworthy that the disparity, albeit not substantial, adds a practical edge to this four-door sedan.

The 2023 Dodge Charger generously provides 16.5 cubic feet of cargo space, a marginal 0.3 cubic feet more than the Challenger. While this difference may not be immediately noticeable when using the trunk in isolation, the Charger's true advantage becomes apparent when you opt to fold down its 60/40 split folding rear seats. This feature grants access to an expanded rear passenger compartment, offering a versatile and accommodating space for cargo.

Conversely, the Challenger also incorporates a 60/40 split folding rear seat configuration. However, the pass-through experience in the Challenger is marked by a narrower space and the challenge of navigating the coupe's 3.1 inches of extra liftover height. This distinction accentuates the Charger's practicality, especially for those seeking a more flexible cargo solution and ease of access to the rear compartment.

In the nuanced interplay between the 2023 Dodge Charger and Challenger, the emphasis on cargo capacity positions the Charger as the more pragmatic choice for those who prioritize versatile storage solutions and a seamless blend of passenger and cargo space.

Challenger vs Charger
Challenger vs Charger

Challenger vs Charger: Safety

Dodge Charger: Winner

When it comes to safety, both the 2023 Dodge Charger and the Dodge Challenger exhibit certain nuances in their performance, showcasing distinctions that are critical for potential buyers to consider. Notably, neither car secured the IIHS' 2023 Top Safety Pick or Top Safety Pick+ awards, with both models encountering challenges in the small overlap front driver-side crash test, resulting in Moderate scores.

In the specific evaluation of roof strength and head restraint tests, the Challenger garnered Average scores, whereas the Charger demonstrated commendable safety performance with Good scores in these areas. This differentiation underscores the Charger's commitment to enhanced safety measures in critical crash scenarios.

One intriguing facet of the safety comparison is the divergent ratings in front crash avoidance technology. The Charger stands out with a Superior rating, showcasing its advanced front crash avoidance tech. In contrast, the Challenger received a Basic rating in this category. This variance may be attributed to the fact that collision mitigation is not available on Challengers equipped with a manual transmission, potentially influencing its safety technology rating.

It's noteworthy that both the 2023 Dodge Charger and Challenger achieved a commendable five-star overall rating from the NHTSA. This overarching assessment underscores a level of reliability and safety across various criteria, providing a holistic perspective on the vehicles' safety performance.

In navigating the safety landscape of the 2023 Dodge Charger vs. Challenger debate, the nuanced differences in crash test scores and safety technology ratings highlight the Charger's edge in certain areas, making it an appealing choice for those placing a premium on advanced safety features and crash protection.

Challenger vs Charger: Overall Cost of Ownership

Dodge Charger: Winner

In the realm of long-term value, the 2023 Dodge Charger emerges as a more favorable choice based on insights from IntelliChoice, offering a promising prospect for those planning to keep their vehicle for an extended period, beyond five years. This assessment takes into account a comprehensive array of factors, including depreciation, insurance, maintenance, repair, fuel costs, and state fees over a five-year duration.

According to IntelliChoice's evaluation, non-Hellcat versions of the Charger garnered ratings ranging from Average to Good. This signifies a solid performance across various metrics that contribute to the overall cost of ownership. On the other hand, the Challenger exhibited a mixed performance with mostly Good and Average ratings but a few instances of Mediocre and Poor results.

Interestingly, both the Charger and Challenger Hellcat models received a Poor rating. However, it's worth noting that such high-performance variants, like the Hellcat models, often carry a unique allure and potential future collector's item status, which might influence the decision to hold onto them for an extended period.

As prospective buyers weigh their options in the 2023 Dodge Charger vs. Challenger comparison, the data from IntelliChoice positions the Charger as a more financially sound choice for those considering a prolonged ownership period. The combination of solid ratings and the potential collector's appeal of certain models further enhances the Charger's position as a compelling option for those seeking enduring value from their automotive investment.

Challenger vs Charger
Challenger vs Charger

Challenger vs Charger: Performance

Dodge Challenger: Winner

In the pursuit of ultimate performance, the 2023 Dodge Challenger stands as the undisputed champion, embodying Dodge's commitment to pushing the boundaries of high-performance trims. This commitment is exemplified by Dodge's strategy of debuting the latest and most powerful features on the Challenger before extending them to the Charger.

The Challenger's trailblazing started with the introduction of the Widebody option in 2018, setting the stage for the Charger to follow suit in 2020. The Challenger SRT Hellcat Redeye, making its debut in 2019 with an astonishing 797 horsepower, eventually found its counterpart in the Charger for the 2023 model year.

As of the latest information, the 2023 Dodge Challenger SRT Super Stock reigns supreme on the drag strip. Boasting an impressive 807 horsepower and 707 lb-ft of torque, this performance powerhouse is equipped with 18x11-inch alloy wheels wrapped in street-legal Nitto drag radials. Notably, the claimed 0-60 time of 3.3 seconds underscores the Challenger's dominance in acceleration and straight-line speed.

One notable feature that sets the Challenger apart is the availability of a manual transmission, a detail that resonates with purists and enthusiasts who relish the tactile connection and control provided by a manual gearbox. Unfortunately, this option is not offered in the Charger, further establishing the Challenger as the go-to choice for those who prioritize the engaging experience of rowing through the gears themselves.

As the 2023 Dodge Challenger takes the lead in the realm of ultimate performance, it continues to set the standard for high-powered, adrenaline-pumping driving experiences, making it an unrivaled choice for enthusiasts seeking the pinnacle of muscle car performance.

Challenger vs Charger: Price

Dodge Challenger: Winner

The pricing dynamics between the Dodge Charger and its two-door counterpart, the Challenger, reveal a consistent trend where the Charger tends to be slightly more expensive across various trim levels. This pricing discrepancy is evident from the base models up to the high-performance variants.

For instance, taking the base 2023 models as an example, the Dodge Charger SXT starts at $34,240, just marking a $155 premium over an equivalent Challenger model. This price difference persists as you progress through the trim levels, gradually expanding. Even in the case of the high-performance SRT Hellcat Redeye Widebody models, the separation narrows, with just a $100 gap.

This pricing strategy reflects the inherent differences in the design, practicality, and performance offerings of the Charger and Challenger. The Charger, with its four-door sedan configuration, provides additional interior space and a more family-friendly design, potentially justifying a slightly higher price point.

As buyers ascend the trim ladder, the pricing gap between the Charger and Challenger is maintained, reinforcing the nuanced choices available to consumers based on their preferences, whether it be the Charger's practicality or the Challenger's distinctive two-door muscle car allure.

In the spectrum of the 2023 Dodge Charger vs. Challenger debate, the pricing structure aligns with the inherent characteristics of each model, allowing buyers to make informed decisions based on their priorities and preferences, be it space, performance, or style.

Challenger vs Charger: Technology

Yes, It’s a Draw:

The similarity in features between the Dodge Charger and Dodge Challenger further underscores the shared platform and design philosophy between the two models. Both cars are equipped with a range of modern amenities, providing a comparable infotainment experience for drivers and passengers.

1. Infotainment System:

· Both the Charger and Challenger boast an 8.4-inch Uconnect touchscreen infotainment system, offering a user-friendly interface and intuitive controls.

· Apple CarPlay and Android Auto phone integration come standard, enabling seamless connectivity for smartphone users.

2. Connectivity:

· The availability of a 4G Wi-Fi hotspot enhances connectivity on the go, allowing occupants to stay connected to the internet for various purposes.

3. SRT Models and Dodge Performance Pages:

· Opting for an SRT model in either the Charger or Challenger lineup provides access to Dodge Performance Pages. This feature empowers drivers to customize vehicle settings, review telemetry data, and engage with other performance-oriented functionalities.

While the core infotainment and connectivity features are consistent between the Charger and Challenger, the availability of Dodge Performance Pages on SRT models adds an extra layer of customization and performance monitoring for enthusiasts. This feature aligns with the high-performance nature of the SRT variants, allowing drivers to fine-tune their driving experience and delve into the performance metrics of their vehicle.

In essence, the shared features between the 2023 Dodge Charger and Challenger contribute to a similar technology and infotainment experience, providing a level playing field for buyers to choose between the two models based on other factors such as body style, practicality, and performance preferences.

Challenger vs Charger: Fuel Economy

Yes, It’s a Draw:

For those considering the 2023 Dodge Charger and Challenger and giving some thought to fuel efficiency, it's evident that these performance-oriented vehicles prioritize power and exhilarating driving experiences over fuel economy. While efficiency might not be the primary concern for enthusiasts in the market for these cars, it's worth noting the similarities and distinctions in their fuel economy ratings, particularly when considering the engine and transmission options.

V-6 Models: The V-6 models in both the Charger and Challenger share identical fuel economy ratings. In rear-wheel-drive (RWD) configuration, they are EPA-rated at 19/30 mpg city/highway, and with all-wheel drive (AWD), the ratings are 18/27 mpg.

5.7-liter V-8 and 6.4-liter V-8 Models: When equipped with the eight-speed automatic transmission, both the 5.7-liter V-8 and 6.4-liter V-8 models share the same fuel economy ratings of 16/25 mpg.

Manual Transmission Models (Challenger Only): The availability of a six-speed manual transmission is exclusive to the Challenger. In this configuration, the 5.7-liter Challenger is rated at 15/23 mpg, and the 6.4-liter Challenger model achieves 14/23 mpg.

While the fuel economy ratings for these performance models may not be groundbreaking, the inclusion of a manual transmission option for the Challenger adds a distinctive touch for those who prioritize the engagement and control offered by a manual gearbox.

In the grand scheme of the Charger vs. Challenger comparison, fuel efficiency may be a secondary consideration for potential buyers, especially when the primary focus is on the high-performance capabilities and distinctive driving experiences these vehicles offer.

Challenger vs Charger
Challenger vs Charger

Challenger vs Charger: Which is Better?

The choice between the Dodge Charger and Challenger ultimately boils down to your specific needs, preferences, and how you intend to use the vehicle. Consider the following factors to help guide your decision:

1. Practicality and Space:

· If you regularly transport passengers or require a more family-friendly option, the four-door design of the Charger may be preferable. It offers additional rear-seat space and a more practical layout for daily use.

2. Daily Driver vs. Weekend Ride:

· Assess whether you're looking for a daily driver or a weekend performance machine. The Charger's more practical design could make it a comfortable and versatile daily driver, while the Challenger's distinctive two-door coupe styling might appeal to those seeking a spirited weekend ride.

3. Styling Preferences:

· Consider your taste in aesthetics. The Challenger boasts in-your-face retro styling, appealing to those who appreciate classic muscle car design. On the other hand, the Charger offers a more subdued but still aggressive four-door look, catering to a different aesthetic preference.

4. Performance Considerations:

· Evaluate your performance requirements. If you desire a balance of sleeper appeal, eye-catching stance, and potent V-8 performance, the Dodge Charger Scat Pack Widebody could be an ideal choice. It combines the practicality of a four-door sedan with impressive performance credentials.

Ultimately, the recommendation of a Dodge Charger Scat Pack Widebody underscores its versatile appeal, offering a blend of performance, style, and everyday practicality. However, your personal priorities and preferences should be the driving force behind your decision. Take both models for a test drive, consider your lifestyle, and choose the one that aligns best with your unique needs and desires. Whether it's the Charger or Challenger, both models have carved out their places in the automotive landscape, catering to different tastes and driving experiences.

Pros of Dodge Charger over Challenger:

  1. Passenger Space:

  1. Pros: The Charger, being a four-door sedan, offers more generous rear passenger space compared to the Challenger, making it a more practical choice for families or those frequently carrying passengers.

  1. Cargo Capacity:

  1. Pros: The Charger has a larger trunk capacity, enhancing its practicality for those requiring more storage space.

  1. Safety:

  1. Pros: The Charger demonstrates strengths in safety features, contributing to higher safety ratings.

  1. Value:

  1. Pros: According to IntelliChoice data, the Charger appears to have a better long-term value, making it a potentially more cost-effective option for buyers considering extended ownership.

Pros of Dodge Challenger over Charger:

  1. Ultimate Performance:

  1. Pros: The Challenger, especially in high-performance trims, holds the edge in terms of ultimate performance, offering powerful engine options and track-focused capabilities.

  1. Manual Transmission:

  1. Pros: The Challenger is available with a manual transmission, providing an engaging driving experience for those who prefer to shift gears manually.

  1. Price:

  1. Pros: The Challenger tends to have a slightly lower base price compared to the Charger, making it an attractive option for those prioritizing cost savings.

FAQs: Challenger vs Charger

Q1: What distinguishes the Dodge Charger from the Challenger in terms of design and purpose?

Both the Dodge Charger and Challenger share the rear-wheel-drive Chrysler LX platform, but their designs cater to different preferences. The Charger, a four-door sedan, blends practicality with performance, while the Challenger, a two-door coupe, emphasizes raw power and a driver-centric experience.

Q2: Which model offers superior passenger space between the Charger and Challenger?

The Dodge Charger takes the lead in passenger space. Its four-door sedan design provides more generous rear legroom, shoulder room, and hiproom compared to the Challenger. The Charger's emphasis on comfort makes it a preferred choice for those valuing spacious interiors.

Q3: How does cargo capacity differ between the Charger and Challenger?

The 2023 Dodge Charger boasts a larger trunk, offering 16.5 cubic feet of cargo space, slightly edging out the Challenger's 16.2 cubic feet. The Charger's advantage becomes more pronounced when its 60/40 split folding rear seats are utilized, providing enhanced versatility.

Q4: In terms of safety, is there a notable difference between the Charger and Challenger?

While both models missed IIHS' 2023 Top Safety Pick awards, the Charger demonstrated strengths in the roof strength and head restraint tests, earning Good scores. The Charger also received a Superior rating for front crash avoidance tech, distinguishing itself in safety technology.

Q5: Which vehicle has a better long-term value according to IntelliChoice?

Based on IntelliChoice data, the 2023 Dodge Charger emerges as a better bet for long-term value. Factors such as depreciation, insurance, maintenance, repair, and fuel costs over a five-year period contribute to the Charger's favorable ratings.

Q6: How does the performance of the Challenger compare to the Charger?

The Dodge Challenger excels in ultimate performance, often receiving the latest high-performance trims before the Charger. It offers powerful engine options, including the Challenger SRT Super Stock with 807 hp, making it the preferred choice for enthusiasts seeking the pinnacle of muscle car performance.

Q7: Is there a manual transmission option available for both the Charger and Challenger?

The manual transmission option is exclusive to the Challenger. Enthusiasts who appreciate the tactile connection and control provided by a manual gearbox can opt for the Challenger, making it the preferred choice for those who enjoy a more engaging driving experience.

Q8: How do the prices of the Charger and Challenger compare across trim levels?

Generally, the Charger tends to be slightly more expensive than the Challenger across various trim levels. The pricing reflects the inherent differences in design, practicality, and performance offerings. Buyers can choose based on their priorities, whether it's the Charger's practicality or the Challenger's distinctive two-door muscle car allure.

Q9: Do the Charger and Challenger offer similar technology features?

Yes, both the Dodge Charger and Challenger share a range of modern amenities, including an 8.4-inch Uconnect touchscreen infotainment system, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and a 4G Wi-Fi hotspot. SRT models in both lineups also provide access to Dodge Performance Pages for customization and performance monitoring.

Q10: How do the fuel economy ratings compare between the Charger and Challenger?

The fuel economy ratings for both models are similar, especially when equipped with the same engines and transmissions. Both V-6 models share identical fuel economy ratings, and the 5.7-liter and 6.4-liter V-8 models exhibit matching fuel efficiency. The Challenger's advantage is the availability of a manual transmission, providing a distinct driving experience for enthusiasts.

Latest Posts