Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma

The 2024 Toyota Tacoma and 2024 Chevrolet Colorado are both powerful pick-up trucks with impressive performance capabilities and towing Capacities.

Salman Chaudhary, Founder Pinkywheels.com

12/11/2023

Tacoma vs Colorado
Tacoma vs Colorado

Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma

2024 Toyota Tacoma Limited vs 2024 Chevy Colorado Z71

In the realm of midsize trucks, the Chevrolet Colorado and Toyota Tacoma emerge as two stalwarts vying for attention. Delving into their offerings reveals a tapestry of features and capabilities, each tailored to appeal to distinct preferences and demands of drivers.

The Chevy Colorado commands attention with its robust 310 horsepower engine and the seamless performance of its eight-speed automatic transmission. Boasting an impressive towing capacity of 7,700 pounds, it's a workhorse ready to tackle hefty loads with ease. Equipped with advanced safety features like pedestrian detection, the Colorado exemplifies modern innovation fused with utility.

Meanwhile, the Toyota Tacoma exudes its own brand of prowess, especially in its Limited trim, where its 278 horsepower engine ensures spirited performance. Though slightly edged out in horsepower by the Colorado, the Tacoma compensates with a commendable towing capacity of 6,500 pounds and thrifty fuel efficiency, achieving 22 mpg combined. Whether navigating city streets or traversing highways, the Tacoma offers a balanced blend of power and economy.

When it comes to off-road adventures, both trucks shine. The Colorado ZR2 and Tacoma TRD Off-Road editions boast specialized features like front and rear locking differentials, catering to the adventurous spirit of drivers seeking rugged terrain. Additionally, the Tacoma's TRD Pro trim elevates off-road capability to new heights, making it a formidable companion for those who dare to explore untamed landscapes.

Inside the cabin, considerations for passenger comfort are evident. The Colorado offers ample rear legroom and customizable climate controls, ensuring a pleasant journey for all occupants. Similarly, the Tacoma provides a comfortable rear seat environment, complemented by intuitive climate management features.

In terms of efficiency, the Colorado achieves a respectable 18 mpg combined, while the Tacoma edges ahead with its 22 mpg rating, making it an appealing option for those conscious of fuel consumption.

Highlights: 2024 Tacoma vs Chevy Colorado

Vehicle Type:

  • Tacoma: Front-engine, rear- or rear/4-wheel-drive, 5-passenger, 2- or 4-door pickup

  • Colorado: Front-engine, rear/4-wheel-drive, 5-passenger, 4-door pickup

Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma - Prices:

  • Tacoma Limited: $53,595

  • Colorado Z71: $41,795

Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma - Powertrains:

  • Tacoma: Turbocharged 2.4L inline-4 with options:

  • 228 hp, 243 lb-ft

  • 270 hp, 310 lb-ft

  • 278 hp, 317 lb-ft

  • Colorado Z71: Turbocharged and intercooled DOHC 16-valve inline-4, aluminum block and head, direct fuel injection

  • Power: 310 hp @ 5600 rpm

  • Torque: 430 lb-ft @ 3000 rpm

Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma - Transmissions:

  • Tacoma: 6-speed manual, 8-speed automatic

  • Colorado ZR2: 8-speed automatic

Chevy Colorado vs Toyota Tacoma - Dimensions:

  • Tacoma:

  • Wheelbase: 131.9–145.1 in

  • Length: 213.0–226.2 in

  • Width: 76.9–77.9 in

  • Height: 73.8–74.7 in

  • Curb Weight: 4200–4800 lb

  • Colorado:

  • Wheelbase: 131.4 in

  • Length: 212.7 in

  • Width: 76.3 in

  • Height: 81.8 in

  • Passenger Volume, F/R: 58/43 ft³

  • Curb Weight: 5000 lb

Performance:

  • Tacoma Limited:

  • 60 mph: 7.0 sec

  • 1/4-Mile: 14.9–16.4 sec

  • Top Speed: 110 mph

  • Colorado Z71:

  • 60 mph: 6.5 sec

  • 1/4-Mile: 14.0 sec

  • Top Speed: 100 mph

EPA Fuel Economy:

  • Tacoma: Combined/City/Highway: 20–23/18–21/23–26 mpg

  • Colorado: Combined/City/Highway: 18/17/19 mpg

Tacoma vs Colorado
Tacoma vs Colorado

Tacoma vs Colorado - Exterior

1. Frontal Design and Grills:

  • Chevy Colorado: The Colorado features a visually toughened front design with a boxier aesthetic. The grill is more aggressive, predominantly black, giving it a bold and rugged appearance.

  • Toyota Tacoma: Also showcasing a toughened-up look, the Tacoma's front design features a more pronounced grill with chrome and silver accents. LED projector headlights and LED fog lamps contribute to its aggressive stance.

2. Lighting and Ground Clearance:

  • Both trucks are equipped with LED projector headlights and LED fog lamps, providing enhanced visibility.

  • Chevy Colorado: Boasts 8.9 inches of ground clearance, ensuring ample space for off-road adventures.

  • Toyota Tacoma: Ground clearance of 11 inches, making it suitable for navigating challenging terrains.

3. Configurations and Wheels:

  • Chevy Colorado: Limited to a four-door crew cab configuration with a 5-ft bed across all trims. Rolls on 18-inch alloy wheels with distinct designs.

  • Toyota Tacoma: Offers a two-door version and a four-door crew cab configuration, catering to different preferences. Features 18-inch alloy wheels with unique designs.

4. Tailgate Features:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Introduces the Stow Flex tailgate with a storage compartment, providing practical solutions for tools or use as a cooler. Power tailgate operation is not present.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Features a power tailgate, allowing remote operation and hands-free closing. Unique innovations like a removable and rechargeable speaker add to its versatility.

5. Mirrors and Safety Features:

  • Both trucks feature heated mirrors with blind-spot monitoring for enhanced safety.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Includes maintenance coverage for the first 2 years, covering more service visits compared to the Colorado. Features the innovative Smart Camera Functionality.

6. Exterior Design Elements:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Emphasizes a rugged appearance with off-road design elements. The rear design features LED-accented lights and dual exhaust outlets.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Presents a refined and sleek rear design with all-LED elements in the lights. Exhaust outlets exit on opposite sides, contributing to a distinctive appearance.

7. Tailgate and Bed Features:

  • Both trucks feature innovative tailgate designs with practical applications.

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Introduces the Stow Flex tailgate, a storage compartment with versatile usage. Class-exclusive bumper steps ease bed access.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Features a power tailgate, a unique offering in the midsize truck segment. A 400W AC inverter enhances utility.

Tacoma vs Colorado - Interior

1. Entry and Starting Experience:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Features smart entry and remote start for convenient access. The door handle requires manual interaction for unlocking.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Smart entry and remote start are present but may require an active subscription for remote services post-trial. The Tacoma's door features a sensor, enabling touch-free unlocking.

2. Interior Materials and Finishes:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: The interior showcases a mix of materials, with some hard surfaces. Leather-covered seats with contrast accents provide a comfortable and visually appealing cabin.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Boasts superior interior materials, including soft-touch surfaces, realistic faux wood decor, and leatherette. The attention to detail elevates the Tacoma's cabin, bringing it closer to full-size truck standards.

3. Seating Comfort and Adjustability:

  • Both trucks offer leather-covered seats with contrast accents and 10-way power adjustment. Heating and ventilation are available in both cabins.

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Introduces memory seats, providing a personalized and convenient driving experience.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Offers 10-way power-adjustable seats with a focus on comfort and support.

4. Cabin Technology:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Equipped with a customizable 8-inch digital gauge cluster and traditional controls. The infotainment screen is 11.3 inches, featuring a variety of functions, including wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Showcases a larger 12.3-inch digital gauge cluster and the latest Toyota infotainment software. The controls for certain features, like fog lamps, are integrated into the infotainment display.

5. Steering Wheel and Driving Controls:

  • Both trucks feature leather-wrapped steering wheels with manual adjustment and heating.

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Presents traditional controls, including a dedicated headlight stock.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Integrates controls into the infotainment display, eliminating the traditional headlight stock.

6. Interior Storage Solutions:

  • Both cabins provide effective storage solutions for convenience during drives.

  • The center consoles are spacious, and both trucks feature wireless phone charging pads.

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Includes a Stow Flex tailgate storage compartment, adding practicality for tools or use as a cooler.

7. Audio Systems and Sound Quality:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Features a seven-speaker Bose audio system, providing a balanced and immersive sound experience.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Equipped with a 10-speaker JBL audio system, offering a rich and high-quality sound profile.

8. Infotainment and Connectivity:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Showcases an 11.3-inch infotainment screen with wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. Controls include a mix of traditional and integrated options.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Boasts a 12.3-inch infotainment screen, matching the latest Toyota infotainment software. Features Wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, providing seamless connectivity.

9. Rear Cabin Amenities:

  • Both trucks, being crew cabs, offer rear seating with considerations for comfort and convenience.

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Features rear vents and a fold-down armrest, enhancing rear passenger comfort.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Slightly smaller rear legroom, but still competitive. Lacks rear vents and fold-down armrest, highlighting a gap in amenities compared to the Colorado.

Tacoma vs Colorado
Tacoma vs Colorado

Tacoma vs Colorado – Engine and Performance

1. Powertrains:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Powered by a turbocharged 2.7L 4-cylinder engine, delivering an impressive 310 horsepower and nearly 400 lb-ft of torque. The transition from traditional V6 engines marks a shift towards enhanced power and efficiency.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Equipped with a turbocharged 2.4L 4-cylinder engine, providing a robust performance with 278 horsepower and 317 lb-ft of torque. The Tacoma's powertrain contributes to a dynamic driving experience, though it lags behind the Colorado in terms of power.

2. Transmission:

  • Both trucks feature upgraded 8-speed automatic transmissions, ensuring smooth and efficient gear shifts.

  • The transmissions in both the Colorado and Tacoma play a crucial role in optimizing power delivery and performance during acceleration or challenging terrains.

3. Acceleration and Speed:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: With its powerful engine, the Colorado demonstrates faster acceleration, reaching 0-60 mph quickly. The turbocharged 4-cylinder engine's nearly 400 lb-ft of torque contributes to a responsive and dynamic driving experience.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Despite a slightly lower power output, the Tacoma offers a robust acceleration, making it a capable performer in various driving scenarios.

4. Off-Road Capability:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Emphasizes off-road prowess, showcasing features like bumper steps and a rugged design. The Z71 trim underlines its capability for off-road adventures.

  • Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road: Retains its reputation as a formidable off-road contender, especially in the TRD Off-Road variant. The Tacoma's design and features contribute to its capability in challenging terrains.

5. Towing Capacity:

  • Chevy Colorado: 7700 Pounds

  • Toyota Tacoma: 6500 Pounds

6. Fuel Efficiency:

  • Both trucks maintain identical fuel efficiency at 21 MPG combined, showcasing a balance between performance and fuel economy.

  • The turbocharged 4-cylinder engines strike a harmonious blend, catering to drivers seeking versatile midsize trucks for various driving scenarios.

7. Transmission and Gear Shifts:

  • Both trucks are equipped with upgraded 8-speed automatic transmissions, contributing to smooth and efficient gear shifts.

  • The transmissions in the Colorado and Tacoma play a crucial role in optimizing power delivery and performance during acceleration or challenging terrains.

Tacoma vs Colorado - Driving Experience

Transmission and Gear Shifts:

  • Both trucks are equipped with upgraded 8-speed automatic transmissions, contributing to smooth and efficient gear shifts.

  • The transmission in the Tacoma complements its turbocharged engine, providing responsive and seamless shifts. The Colorado's transmission ensures optimal power utilization, especially during acceleration or challenging terrains.

Ride Quality and Suspension:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: While maintaining commendable ride quality, the Z71 lacks adaptive dampers. This may result in a slightly firmer feel over uneven surfaces.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Introduces adaptive dampers, a unique feature in the midsize truck segment. These dampers significantly impact ride quality, enhancing comfort and reducing vibrations for a more refined driving experience.

Handling and Maneuverability:

  • Both trucks handle bumps and potholes with ease, showcasing their capability for on-road driving.

  • The Tacoma, with adaptive dampers, exhibits improved handling dynamics, making it feel less truck-like and more refined. The Colorado, particularly in the Z71 trim, emphasizes its off-road capability while maintaining on-road comfort.

Noise Levels and Cabin Comfort:

  • Noise ratings at 57 and 57.4 decibels for the Colorado and Tacoma, respectively, at 55 mph showcase a commitment to minimizing road and wind noise.

  • The cabins are designed for a quieter and more comfortable driving environment, enhancing the overall driving experience.

Fuel Efficiency:

  • Both trucks maintain identical fuel efficiency at 21 MPG combined, showcasing a balance between performance and fuel economy.

  • The turbocharged engines strike a harmonious blend, appealing to drivers seeking versatility for various driving scenarios.

Off-Road Capability:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Emphasizes off-road prowess with features like bumper steps, providing a rugged feel for off-road enthusiasts.

  • Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road: Retains its reputation as a formidable off-road contender, offering capabilities to tackle challenging terrains.

Tacoma vs Colorado - Safety Features Overview

Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS):

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Offers a range of ADAS, including forward collision alert, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking. These systems contribute to collision prevention and driver awareness.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Equips advanced safety features like adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning, and forward collision warning. The Tacoma's ADAS enhances overall safety during highway and urban driving.

Blind Spot Monitoring and Rear Cross Traffic Alert:

  • Both trucks are equipped with blind-spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert systems. These features enhance awareness and help prevent collisions when changing lanes or reversing.

Safety Package Requirements:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Requires the selection of the Safety and Technology packages to access certain advanced safety features. These packages enhance the truck's safety profile.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Includes a comprehensive set of safety features without additional package requirements, providing a seamless integration of safety technologies.

Maintenance Coverage:

  • Chevy Colorado Z71: Offers maintenance coverage for the first year, requiring additional packages for extended coverage. The coverage includes specific service visits to ensure ongoing vehicle health.

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Extends maintenance coverage for the first 2 years, covering more service visits compared to the Colorado. This can contribute to reduced ownership costs and enhanced peace of mind.

Rearview Camera:

  • Both trucks are equipped with rearview cameras, aiding in parking maneuvers and providing increased visibility when reversing.

Active Safety Technologies:

  • Both the Colorado Z71 and Tacoma Limited incorporate active safety technologies, such as automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning, contributing to a safer driving experience.

Smart Camera Functionality:

  • Toyota Tacoma Limited: Introduces smart camera functionality, enhancing overall safety with intelligent camera-based features. This feature contributes to a more comprehensive safety suite.

Child Safety Features:

  • Both trucks incorporate child safety features, including latch systems for securing child seats. Ensuring the safety of younger passengers is a priority in the design of these midsize trucks.

Crash Test Ratings:

  • Both the Chevy Colorado and Toyota Tacoma typically undergo crash testing by organizations such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). These tests assess the trucks' crashworthiness and safety performance.

Tacoma vs Colorado
Tacoma vs Colorado

Tacoma vs Colorado - Pros and Cons

2024 Toyota Tacoma:

Pros:

  1. Robust Off-Road Capability: Tacoma, especially in TRD Off-Road trim, excels in off-road adventures with features tailored for challenging terrains.

  2. Superior Interior Materials: Boasts a high-quality interior with soft-touch surfaces, realistic faux wood decor, and leatherette, elevating cabin aesthetics.

  3. Smart Camera Functionality: Introduces intelligent camera-based features, enhancing overall safety and contributing to a more comprehensive safety suite.

Cons:

  1. Slightly Lower Towing Capacity: Falls short in towing capacity compared to the Colorado, making it less suitable for heavy towing requirements.

  2. Limited Rear Cabin Amenities: Lacks rear vents and a fold-down armrest, providing slightly fewer amenities for rear passengers compared to the Colorado.

  3. Remote Service Subscription: Requires an active subscription for remote services post-trial, potentially adding to ownership costs.

2024 Chevy Colorado:

Pros:

  1. Impressive Towing Capacity: Boasts significantly higher towing capacity, making it a top choice for those prioritizing towing capabilities in a midsize truck.

  2. Innovative Tailgate Design: Features the Stow Flex tailgate with a storage compartment, adding practical solutions for tools or use as a cooler.

  3. Diverse Configuration Options: Offers a limited four-door crew cab configuration with a 5-ft bed across all trims, providing flexibility for various preferences.

Cons:

  1. Interior Material Mix: Showcases a mix of materials with some hard surfaces in the interior, potentially reducing the overall perceived quality.

  2. Limited Rear Cabin Amenities: While better equipped than the Tacoma, the rear cabin lacks certain amenities found in larger vehicles.

  3. Maintenance Coverage Duration: Offers maintenance coverage for the first year, requiring additional packages for extended coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

1. What is the towing capacity of the 2024 Toyota Tacoma?

  • The 2024 Toyota Tacoma has a towing capacity of 6500 Pounds.

2. Does the 2024 Chevy Colorado offer a power tailgate?

  • No, the 2024 Chevy Colorado does not offer a power tailgate. Instead, it features the Stow Flex tailgate with a storage compartment.

3. What safety features are included in the base models of both trucks?

  • Both trucks come equipped with essential safety features, including rearview cameras and blind-spot monitoring.

4. Are there different bed length options for the Chevy Colorado?

  • The Chevy Colorado is limited to a four-door crew cab configuration with a 5-ft bed across all trims.

5. How does the fuel efficiency of the Tacoma compare to the Colorado?

  • Both the Tacoma and Colorado maintain identical fuel efficiency at 21 MPG combined.

6. What is the ground clearance of the 2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road?

  • The 2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road boasts a ground clearance of 11 inches, suitable for navigating challenging terrains.

7. Are adaptive dampers available in any trim of the Chevy Colorado?

  • No, adaptive dampers are not available in the Chevy Colorado Z71, potentially impacting ride quality on uneven surfaces.

8. Can you fold down the rear seats in both trucks for additional cargo space?

  • Yes, both the Toyota Tacoma and Chevy Colorado offer the option to fold down the rear seats for increased cargo space.

9. Is wireless phone charging available in both trucks?

  • Yes, both the Tacoma and Colorado feature wireless phone charging pads for added convenience.

10. How do the crash test ratings compare for the 2024 Toyota Tacoma and Chevy Colorado?

  • Both trucks typically undergo crash testing, with organizations such as the NHTSA and IIHS assessing their crashworthiness and safety performance.

Comparison Video and More Comparisons Follows